Skip to main content Skip to main navigation menu Skip to site footer
Responsive image
Issue: Vol. 714 No. 1: 6 Aug. 2025
Type: Article
Published: 2025-08-06
DOI: 10.11646/phytotaxa.714.1.2
Page range: 40-56
Abstract views: 425
PDF downloaded: 5

A review of the nomenclature and identity of Cotyledon mucronata and C. undulata (Crassulaceae subfam. Cotyledonoideae), two names variously applied to undulate leaf-margined material generally included in the synonymy of different varieties of C. orbiculata, with C. mucronata reinstated at the rank of species

Ria Olivier Herbarium, Department of Botany, Nelson Mandela University, P.O. Box 77000, Gqeberha, 6031 South Africa
Biodiversity Research and Monitoring Directorate, South African National Biodiversity Institute, P.O. Box 52099, Berea Road, Durban, 4007 South Africa
South Africa south-tropical Africa synonymy taxonomy Eudicots

Abstract

As circumscribed at present, Cotyledon (Crassulaceae subfam. Cotyledonoideae) is a small genus of about two dozen species. For the species and infraspecific taxa recognised in Cotyledon, almost 100 names are available. This resulted from the naming, especially at the rank of species, of the extraordinary natural variability of at least some of the recognised Cotyledon taxa. In some of the Cotyledon species upheld at present, a range of taxa are treated at the rank of varietas. For example, in C. orbiculata, four varieties are recognised in addition to the autonymic one. Horticulturally popular undulate leaf-margined variants of C. orbiculata, as attributed at present, were described as C. mucronata by J-B.P.A. de M. de Lamarck in 1786 and later redescribed as C. undulata by A.H. Haworth in 1819, with, in the protologues of both these names, a plate (and only that plate) published by Johannes [Johan] Burman in 1738 being unambiguously cited. Yet, C. mucronata was most recently placed in the synonymy of the autonymic C. orbiculata var. orbiculata and C. undulata in the synonymy of C. orbiculata var. oblonga. In this paper the nomenclature and taxonomy associated with these two names are revisited and clarified. We show that the two names, i.e., C. mucronata and C. undulata, are homotypic and that the name C. undulata is illegitimate and nomenclaturally superfluous. If the undulate-leaf margined variant of the broadly defined C. orbiculata is recognised at the rank of species—a view we implement here—the name to adopt is C. mucronata. The name C. undulata belongs in the synonymy of C. mucronata.

References

  1. Adanson, M. (1763 [July–August]) Familles des plantes. Contenant une Préface Historike sur l’état ancien & actuel de la Botanike, & une Téorie de cette Science. II. Partie. Chez Vincent, Imprimeur-Libraire de Mgr le Comte de Provence, rue S. Severin, Paris, 640 pp. [https://www.biodiversitylibrary.org/item/6958#page/794/mode/1up]
  2. Barrie, F.R. (2006 [August]) Report of the General Committee: 9. Taxon 55 (3): 795–800. https://doi.org/10.2307/25065657
  3. Berger, A. (1930 [Mai]) Crassulaceae. Unterfam. II. Kalanchoideae [sic, Kalanchooideae]. 6. Kalanchoe Adanson. 7. Kitchingia Baker. 8. Bryophyllum Salisb. Unterfam. III. Cotyledonoideae. In: Engler, A. & Prantl, K. (Eds.) Die natürlichen Pflanzenfamilien, edn 2, 18a. Verlag von Wilhelm Engelmann, Leipzig, pp. 378–386, 402–412.
  4. Brickell, C.D., Alexander, C., Cubey, J.J., David, J.C., Hoffman, M.H.A., Leslie, A.C., Malécot, V. & Xiaobai, J. (2016 [June]) International code of nomenclature for cultivated plants (ICNCP or Cultivated Plant Code), incorporating the Rules and Recommendations for naming plants in cultivation adopted by the International Union of Biological Sciences and the International Commission for the Nomenclature of Cultivated Plants. 9th edn. International Society for Horticultural Science (ISHS), Leuven, Belgium, Scripta Horticulturae 18: 1–190. [https://www.ishs.org/sites/default/files/static/ScriptaHorticulturae_18.pdf]
  5. Britton, N.L. & Rose, J.N. (1903) New or noteworthy North American Crassulaceae. Bulletin of the New York Botanical Garden 3 (9): 1–45. [https://www.biodiversitylibrary.org/item/97293#page/17/mode/1up]
  6. Burman, J. (1738) Rariorum africanarum plantarum: ad vivum delineatarum, iconibus ac descriptionibus illustratarum. Decas secunda. Apud Henricum Boussiere, Amstelaedami [Amsterdam], pp. 23–46, Tab. 11–20. [https://bibdigital.rjb.csic.es/viewer/13614/?offset=#page=29&viewer=picture&o=bookmark&n=0&q= (Tab. 19, Figure 2); https://bibdigital.rjb.csic.es/viewer/13614/?offset=#page=31&viewer=picture&o=bookmark&n=0&q= (Text)]
  7. Burman, J. (1738–1739) Rariorum africanarum plantarum: ad vivum delineatarum, iconibus ac descriptionibus illustratarum. Decas prima-decima. Apud Henricum Boussiere, Amstelaedami [Amsterdam], published in 10 parts with continuous pagination, Tab. I–C [1–100], pp. 1–268. [https://bibdigital.rjb.csic.es/idurl/1/13623]
  8. Candolle, A.P. de. (1801) Histoire naturelle. Botanique. Extrait d’un mémoire sur la famille des Joubarbes. Bulletin des Sciences, par la Société Philomathique (de Paris) 3 (49): 1–2. [https://www.biodiversitylibrary.org/page/5495103#page/9/mode/1up]
  9. Candolle, A.P. de. (1828 [mid-March]) Prodromus systematis naturalis regni vegetabilis, sive enumeratio contracta ordinum, generum, specierumque plantarum huc usque cognitarum, juxta methodi naturalis normas digesta. Pars Tertia. [Umbilicus DC. Treated on p. 399]. Sistens Calyciflorarum Ordines XXVI. Sumptibus Sociorum Treuttel et Wurtz, rue de Bourbon, no 17, Paris, & Strasbourg & London, 494 pp. [https://www.biodiversitylibrary.org/page/152793#page/410/mode/1up]
  10. Crouch, N.R. & Smith, G.F. (2023) Cotyledon mckayi (Crassulaceae subfam. Kalanchooideae), a new cremnophytic species from the central Tugela River Basin of KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa. Phytotaxa 632 (2): 184–192. https://doi.org/10.11646/phytotaxa.632.2.8
  11. Crouch, N.R., Styles, D.G.A. & Walters, M. (2021) Cotyledon nielsii (Crassulaceae), a new cremnophyte from KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa. Bradleya 39: 131–137. https://doi.org/10.25223/brad.n39.2021.a12
  12. Gunn, M.D. & Codd, L.E.W. (1981) Botanical exploration of southern Africa. An illustrated history of early botanical literature on the Cape flora. Biographical accounts of the leading plant collectors and their activities in southern Africa from the days of the East India Company until modern times. A.A. Balkema, Cape Town, 400 pp.
  13. Haworth, A.H. (1803 [July–December]) Miscellanea naturalia, sive dissertationes variae ad historiam naturalem spectantes. [Cotyledon caespitosa, as ‘cespitosa’ Haw. on p. 180 in Disertatio quinta; sive descriptions viginti-quatuor novarum specierum plantarum, cum locis natalibus temporibusque florendi.]. Typis J. Taylor, Londini [London], 204 pp.; ‘Errata et Corrigenda’ page not numbered. [https://archive.org/details/miscellaneanatu00hawogoog/page/n186/mode/2up]
  14. Haworth, A.H. (1812) Synopsis plantarum succulentarum, cum descriptionibus, synonymis, locis; observationibus anglicanis, culturaque. Typis Richardi Taylor et Socii, Shoe-Lane, Londoni, 334 pp.; including 14 numbered “APPENDIX” pages. https://doi.org/10.5962/bhl.title.9462
  15. Haworth, A.H. (1819) Supplementum plantarum succulentarum, sistens plantas novas vel nuper introductas, sive omissas in Synopse Plantarum Succulentarum: cum observationibus variis anglicanis. Adjungitur narcissorum revisio. Multum adhuc restat—multumque restabit. Impensis J. Harding, St. James’s Street, Londini [London], 158 [160] pp. https://doi.org/10.5962/bhl.title.9314
  16. Hemsley, W.B. (1903) Cotyledon undulata. Native of South Africa. Nat. Ord. Crassulaceæ. Genus Cotyledon, Linn.; (Benth. et Hook. f. Gen. Plant. vol. i. p. 659.) Curtis’s Botanical Magazine 129 [of the whole work, volume LIX of the 3rd series]: Tab. 7931. [https://www.biodiversitylibrary.org/item/14257#page/238/mode/1up]
  17. Hooker, J.D. (1868) Cotyledon velutina. Velvety-leaved Cotyledon. Nat. Ord. Crassulaceæ.—Decandria Pentagynia. Curtis’s Botanical Magazine 94 [of the whole work, volume XXV of the 3rd series]: Tab. 5684. [https://www.biodiversitylibrary.org/item/14370#page/8/mode/1up]
  18. IPNI. (2024+) The International Plant Names Index. Available from: https://www.ipni.org/ (accessed December 2024)
  19. Jacobsen, H. (1954) Handbuch der sukkulenten Pflanzen. Beschreibung und Kultur der Sukkulenten mit Ausnahme der Cactaceae. Band I. Abromeitiella bis Euphorbia. [Cotyledon on pp. 355–374.] VEB Gustav Fischer Verlag, Jena, pp. I–XI; 1–614.
  20. Jarvis, C.E. (2007) Order out of chaos. Linnaean plant names and their types. The Linnean Society of London in association with Natural History Museum, London, 1016 pp.
  21. Karsten, M.C. (1951) The old Company’s garden at the Cape & its superintendents. Involving an historical account of early Cape botany. Maskew Miller Limited, Cape Town, 188 pp.
  22. Lamarck, J-B.P.A. de M. de. (1786 [16 October]) Encyclopédie méthodique. Botanique. Tome second, 1. [Cotyledon L. sensu lato, i.e., including Kalanchoe, treated on pp. 139–142.] Chez Panckoucke, Libraire, Hôtel de Thou, rue des Poitevins, Paris, and Chez Plomteux, Imprimeur des Etats, Liège, 774 pp. [https://www.biodiversitylibrary.org/item/15260#page/141/mode/1up]
  23. Lemaire, A.C. (1852) Genre nouveau de la familie des Crassulacées. Adromischus. Jardin Fleuriste; Journal General des Progres et des Interets Horticoles et Botaniques. Ghent 2: 58–61. [https://www.biodiversitylibrary.org/item/274797#page/292/mode/1up]
  24. Linnaeus, C. (1753) Species plantarum, exhibentes plantas rite cognitas, ad genera relatas, cum differentiis specificis, nominibus trivialibus, synonymis selectis, locis natalibus, secundum systema sexuale digestas. Volumes 1 and 2. Salvius, Stockholm, 560 pp. [volume 1] and 1200 pp. [total]; indices not paginated. https://doi.org/10.5962/bhl.title.669
  25. Linnaeus, C. (1762) Species plantarum, exhibentes plantas rite cognitas, ad genera relatas, cum differentiis specificis, nominibus trivialibus, synonymis selectis, locis natalibus, secundum systema sexuale digestas. Tomus I. Editio secunda. Impensis direct. Laurentii Salvii, Holmiæ [Stockholm], 784 pp. https://doi.org/10.5962/bhl.title.11179
  26. Lotsy, J.P. & Goddijn, W.A. (1928) Voyages of exploration to judge of the bearing of hybridisation upon evolution. I. South Africa. [Cotyledon and Tylecodon dealt with predominantly on pp. 5–34, but also elsewhere]. Genetica 10: Text volume: [I]–VIII, [1]–315, Platen [Plates] volume: Tabs I–XI (in colour).
  27. Mort, M.E., Levsen, N., Randle, C.P., Van Jaarsveld, E.J. & Palmer, A. (2005 [July]) Phylogenetics and diversification of Cotyledon (Crassulaceae) inferred from nuclear and chloroplast DNA sequence data. American Journal of Botany 92 (7): 1170–1176. https://doi.org/10.3732/ajb.92.7.1170
  28. Nicolson, D.H. (Ed.) (1992 [August]) Proposals to conserve or reject. Seventy-two proposals for the conservation of types of selected Linnaean generic names, the report of Subcommittee 3C on the lectotypification of Linnaean generic names. Taxon 41 (3): 552–583. https://doi.org/10.1002/j.1996-8175.1992.tb02575.x
  29. Nowell, T.L. (2008 [February]) The spatial and temporal dynamics of diversification in Tylecodon, Cotyledon and Adromischus (Crassulaceae) in southern Africa. Ph.D. dissertation, Department of Botany, Faculty of Science, University of Cape Town, Cape Town, South Africa, 143 pp, including two Appendices. [http://hdl.handle.net/11427/6152]
  30. Pope, A. (1713, [‘1712’]) An essay on criticism: written by Mr. Pope. Second edition. Printed for W. Lewis, London, 36 pp.
  31. Rowley, G.D. (2007) Cotyledon orbiculata and its cultivars. Cactus and Succulent Journal (U.S.) 79 (4): 148–151, 185.
  32. Schönland, S. & Baker, E.G. (1902a [January]) Some South African species of Cotyledon. The Journal of Botany. British and Foreign XL (No. 469): 9–23. [https://www.biodiversitylibrary.org/item/109460#page/16/mode/1up]
  33. Schönland, S. & Baker, E.G. (1902b [March]) Some South African species of Cotyledon. (Plates 431–435) (Concluded from p. 23). The Journal of Botany. British and Foreign XL (No. 471): 89–94, with Plates 431–435 preceding the text. [https://www.biodiversitylibrary.org/item/109460#page/110/mode/1up]
  34. Smith, G.F. (2024) A review and analysis of the nomenclature and taxonomy of the genus-rank synonyms of Kalanchoe (Crassulaceae subfam. Kalanchooideae) published between 1763 and 1956. Phytotaxa 659 (3): 236–254. https://doi.org/10.11646/phytotaxa.659.3.2
  35. Smith, G.F. & Figueiredo, E. (2024) A review and analysis of the early nomenclature and taxonomy associated with the genus name Kalanchoe (Crassulaceae subfam. Kalanchooideae), published by Michel Adanson (1727–1806) in 1763, with notes on the late-18th century taxonomy of the genus. Phytotaxa 633 (2): 108–124. https://doi.org/10.11646/phytotaxa.633.2.2
  36. Smith, G.F., Figueiredo, E., Victor, J. & Klopper, R.R. (2023) Plant poaching in southern Africa is aided by taxonomy. Is a return to Caput bonae spei inevitable? Taxon 72 (4): 717–723. https://doi.org/10.1002/tax.12882
  37. Smith, G.F. & Monro, A.M. (2024) The correct name for the subfamily containing Kalanchoe is Crassulaceae subfam. Cotyledonoideae, and not Crassulaceae subfam. Kalanchooideae, with amendment of the circumscription of Crassulaceae subfam. Cotyledonoideae. Phytotaxa 672 (3): 293–298. https://doi.org/10.11646/phytotaxa.672.3.7
  38. Stapel, J.B. à. (1644) Theophrasti eresii de historia plantarum libri decem. Græcè & Latinè. In quibus textum Græcum variis lectionibus, emendationibus, hiulcorum supplementis: Latinam Gazæ versionem nova interpretatione ad margines: totum opus absolutissimis cum notis, tum commentariis: item rariorum plantarum iconibus illustravit Ioannes Bodæus à Stapel, medicus Amstelodamensis. Accesserunt Iulii Cæsaris Scaligeri in eosdem libros animadversiones: et Roberti Constantini annotationes. Cum indice locupletissimo. Apud Henricum Laurentium, Amstelodami [Amsterdam], 1187 pp. [Index pages not numbered]
  39. Thiers, B. (2024+ [continuously updated]) Index herbariorum: a global directory of public herbaria and associated staff. New York Botanical Garden’s Virtual Herbarium. Available from: http://sweetgum.nybg.org/ih/ (accessed 1 December 2024)
  40. Tölken, H.R. (1978) New taxa and new combinations in Cotyledon and allied genera. Bothalia 12 (3): 377–393. https://doi.org/10.4102/abc.v12i3.1794
  41. Tölken, H.R. (1979) A re-evaluation of the Cotyledon orbiculata complex. Bothalia 12 (4): 615–620. https://doi.org/10.4102/abc.v12i4.1425
  42. Tölken, H.R. (1985) Crassulaceae. 3164, Cotyledon. In: Leistner, O.A. (Ed.) Flora of Southern Africa 14. Botanical Research Institute, Department of Agriculture and Water Supply, likely Pretoria, pp. 3–18.
  43. Turland, N.J., Wiersema, J.H., Barrie, F.R., Gandhi, K.N., Gravendyck, J., Greuter, W., Hawksworth, D.L., Herendeen, P.S., Klopper, R.R., Knapp, S., Kusber, W.-H., Li, D.-Z., May, T.W., Monro, A.M., Prado, J., Price, M.J., Smith, G.F. & Zamora Señoret, J.C. (2025) International Code of Nomenclature for algae, fungi, and plants (Madrid Code). Regnum Vegetabile 162. The University of Chicago Press, Chicago and London, 288 pp. https://doi.org/10.7208/chicago/9780226839479.001.0001
  44. Van Jaarsveld, E. (2003) Cotyledon. In: Eggli, U. (Ed.) Illustrated handbook of succulent plants: Crassulaceae. Springer-Verlag, Berlin, Heidelberg and New York, pp. 27–32.
  45. Van Jaarsveld, E. & Koutnik, D. (2004) Cotyledon and Tylecodon. Umdaus Press, Hatfield [Pretoria], 156 pp.
  46. Von Poellnitz, J.K.L.A. (1937) Beitrӓge zur Kenntnis der Gattung Cotyledon L. Repertorium specierum novarum regni vegetabilis. [Centralblatt (Zentralblatt) für Sammlung und Veröffentlichung von Einzeldiagnosen neuer Pflanzen. Leipzig, Berlin] 42: 15–42.
  47. Walker, C.C. (2022) Cotyledon—a small, highly diverse and complex African genus. CactusWorld 40 (1): 5–14.
  48. Wiersema, J.H., Turland, N.J., Barrie, F.R., Greuter, W., Hawksworth, D.L., Herendeen, P.S., Knapp, S., Kusber, W.-H., Li, D.-Z., Marhold, K., May, T.W., McNeill, J., Monro, A.M., Prado, J., Price, M.J. & Smith, G.F. (Eds.) (2018+ [continuously updated]) International Code of Nomenclature for algae, fungi, and plants (Shenzhen Code) adopted by the Nineteenth International Botanical Congress Shenzhen, China, July 2017: Appendices I–VII. Available online at: https://naturalhistory2.si.edu/botany/codes-proposals/ (accessed 15 December 2024)
  49. Wilson, M.L., Toussaint van Hove-Exalto, Th. & Van Rijssen, W.J.J. (2002) Codex Witsenii. Annotated watercolours of landscapes, flora and fauna observed on the expedition to the Copper Mountains in the country of the Namaqua undertaken in 1685–6 by Simon van der Stel, Commander of the Cape of Good Hope. Copied at the Cape in 1692 for Nicolaas Witsen, Mayor of Amsterdam, Member of the Amsterdam Chamber of the Dutch East India Company, Ambassador to Great Britain, &c, &c. Iziko Museums of Cape Town and Davidii Media, Amsterdam, Cape Town and Amsterdam, 190 pp.

How to Cite

Smith, G.F. & Crouch, N.R. (2025) A review of the nomenclature and identity of Cotyledon mucronata and C. undulata (Crassulaceae subfam. Cotyledonoideae), two names variously applied to undulate leaf-margined material generally included in the synonymy of different varieties of C. orbiculata, with C. mucronata reinstated at the rank of species. Phytotaxa 714 (1): 40–56. https://doi.org/10.11646/phytotaxa.714.1.2